![anybody know of a good dupe for the discontinued nyx butter gloss shade cookie butter? : r/MakeupLounge anybody know of a good dupe for the discontinued nyx butter gloss shade cookie butter? : r/MakeupLounge](https://i.redd.it/anybody-know-of-a-good-dupe-for-the-discontinued-nyx-butter-v0-pt76rmrjnfma1.jpg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=782cbaa4fc9818339d4dc7ff23dad1f19f01ad0d)
anybody know of a good dupe for the discontinued nyx butter gloss shade cookie butter? : r/MakeupLounge
![NYX nude butter gloss shade range, I thought this was a cool display. Yes, it's the bare minimum but still : r/BeautyGuruChatter NYX nude butter gloss shade range, I thought this was a cool display. Yes, it's the bare minimum but still : r/BeautyGuruChatter](https://i.redd.it/o78o5tz1jhl91.jpg)
NYX nude butter gloss shade range, I thought this was a cool display. Yes, it's the bare minimum but still : r/BeautyGuruChatter
![NYX Professional Makeup Shine Loud Vegan High Shine Long-Lasting Liquid Lipstick, Never Basic | Walgreens NYX Professional Makeup Shine Loud Vegan High Shine Long-Lasting Liquid Lipstick, Never Basic | Walgreens](https://pics.walgreens.com/prodimg/642108/450.jpg)
NYX Professional Makeup Shine Loud Vegan High Shine Long-Lasting Liquid Lipstick, Never Basic | Walgreens
![anybody know of a good dupe for the discontinued nyx butter gloss shade cookie butter? : r/MakeupLounge anybody know of a good dupe for the discontinued nyx butter gloss shade cookie butter? : r/MakeupLounge](https://i.redd.it/anybody-know-of-a-good-dupe-for-the-discontinued-nyx-butter-v0-pjbsfnrjnfma1.jpg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=edd1b9d14ee6f57c99ec3406c4e5fc2c40ec567b)